A prototype may be built to examine geometry, assembly, or functional performance. Before production starts, clarify which drawing revision it represents, how it was made, and which of its characteristics have been approved.
Agree the approval plan with the customer before making the sample. Tests, records, and the decision owner should match the part application. The result of a limited review cannot be generalized to every characteristic or future production.
Define the Purpose of the Sample First
Write down the sample's purpose: checking shape, fit, manufacturability, or evaluating a product made by the production process. A sample produced by another method may be useful for assembly, but its properties and process behavior must be interpreted within that method's limits.
In the sample report, state what was tested, which part revision the result applies to, and which checks are deferred. This prevents designers, manufacturers, and customers from interpreting “sample approved” differently.
Fix the Drawing Revision and Acceptance Criteria Before Testing
Before submitting a sample, identify the drawing, model, and agreed changes by revision number or date. Several similar files without a controlled authority make the result difficult to evaluate. If a geometry change was proposed during manufacturing, its approval status should appear in the sample information.
Also list the characteristics to be reviewed: dimensions, appearance, interfaces, material, and required tests. The phrase “to match sample” is clearer when the relevant reference feature is identified. There should also be a question-and-decision route for differences between the drawing and sample.
- 1Freeze the technical authority
- 2Build the sample
- 3Inspect and record results
- 4Correct and review
- 5Obtain customer approval
- 6Monitor series production
Separate As-Cast and Finished-Part Reviews
Each stage can provide different information. The table is a coordination template; its exact scope depends on the project.
| Stage | Review Focus | Expected Output |
|---|---|---|
| As-cast sample | As-cast geometry, appearance, and defined raw characteristics | Acceptance result or list of as-cast corrections |
| Finished sample | Machined surfaces, assembly, and required tests | Inspection result for the product in its final condition |
| Production readiness | Controlled revision, inspection method, and open-item status | Release to start within the agreed scope |
For an order that includes machining, the final sample should also have completed the agreed finishing operations. At Novin Industrial Group, sample-submission sequence and required records are defined during the technical review of each order. The Laboratory & Quality Control page explains the related stages.
Turn Sample Feedback into an Actionable Decision
Effective feedback should identify a specific characteristic. If the part does not fit in assembly, record the problem location, test conditions, and observed result. Then determine whether the proposed correction concerns product design, die, process, or finishing operation. Photographs and annotations can help explain the issue, but they do not replace dimensions and clear criteria.
For every open item, identify the reviewer and decision status. After a correction, record which characteristic was rechecked and which document changed. This turns sample approval into a retrievable record and reduces disputes about previous corrections.
Define Approval Records to Suit the Project
In its introduction to PPAP, AIAG addresses conformity to design records and specifications under an actual production run at production rate. [1] If the customer requires PPAP, define customer-specific requirements, records, submission level, and approver before execution. Do not assume one fixed package or default level for every order.
ISO 9001 certification also does not replace part approval. A joint ISO/IAF statement clarifies that certification applies to the quality management system and is not a certificate of product conformity. [2]
When PPAP is not required, list the necessary records in the project agreement—for example, the controlled drawing, dimensional report, test results, and recorded customer approval. Define who prepares each document and its acceptance criterion.
Link Production Release to the Approved Revision
Before series production, review open items and conditional approvals. If a release applies only to a defined quantity or stage, record that scope. Changes to design, material, or operations that affect requirements should be reviewed under the customer agreement and reapproved when necessary.
Prototype approval differs from acceptance of production lots. NIST describes acceptance sampling as a decision about a lot based on a sampling plan. [3] The result of one sample does not guarantee that every later part will conform. The controlled revision, control plan, identification method, and packaging should be ready at production release. Submit approval requirements through Start a Project together with the part information.
Before Approving the First Sample
- Define the sample's purpose and manufacturing method.
- Record the controlled drawing and model revision.
- Define the characteristics and tests to be approved.
- Review as-cast and finished product within a clear scope.
- Link feedback and corrections to specific characteristics.
- Agree PPAP records and submission level only when required by the project.
- Record approval scope, open items, and conditions for starting production.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does approval of one sample mean all later production is accepted?
Approval should have a defined scope, and later production should follow the controlled revision and control plan. One sample result does not replace inspection and acceptance of subsequent lots.
Does every project require PPAP?
It depends on customer requirements, industry, and the project agreement. Document type and submission level should be defined before execution; one package should not be assumed for every order.
What should happen if the drawing changes after sample approval?
Review the change's effect on the part, die, operations, and controls, and identify the new revision. The scope of resampling or reapproval should be coordinated with and documented by the customer's technical representative.
References and Further Reading
- AIAG — Production Part Approval Process ↗Overview of the production-part approval process and evaluation of design-requirement fulfillment in production.
- ISO/IAF — Expected Outcomes for Accredited Certification to ISO 9001 ↗Scope and intended outcomes of ISO 9001 quality-management-system certification.
- NIST/SEMATECH e-Handbook — What is Acceptance Sampling? ↗Acceptance-sampling concepts and decisions about lot acceptance.
Clarify Sample-Approval Criteria from the Start
State critical characteristics and required tests when defining the project so the sampling stage and criteria for entering series production remain traceable.
View the Related Capability → Send Project Information and Start a Review